New Road Bike… at last

Finally bought a new road bike.  After months of test rides, research and calculation I have finally ended the frustration for at least one bike shop by buying something. What a thing the Trek Domane 4.5 is.

A Trek Domane 4.5 yesterday.  Mine is not quite as clean

The options

My existing road bike was adequate; surprisingly so.  After the heavy wheels of my MTB, it was great to accelerate comparatively light 27″ wheels.  But as I repaired one part and then another and found parts hard to come by (where’s the eccentric bike shop owner with loads of dust-covered New Old Stock) I considered a new road bike.

My first thoughts were to buy a Cyclo-cross bike, which have only recently appeared on the Australian market.  Why not get a frame capable of taking wide or skinny tyres with braze-ons for mudguards and racks and powerful disc brakes.  I could ride on- or off-road by swapping wheels.  That would be great for blasting good times on the smooth tracks that would never be beaten.  Among others I considered the Specialized Tricross.   However, the reality is a bit harsh: you pay more than an equivalent road bike, the frame is heavier and less compliant.  The ride was not much smoother than my steel bike, despite the wide tyres.

Immediately after, I rode a Specialized Roubaix Comp.  The ride was so soft by comparison to the Tricross that I thought I’d broken it.  The frame was so plush and compliant that the footpath bumps dissolved, but the Pavé seat post was bendy to the point of being disconcerting; the saddle rotated rearwards under light pressure from my hand let alone my weight.  It felt like the sag on my MTB before I pumped up the rear shock.  A few weeks later I tried the same bike with a solid alloy post and found it much nicer.  Though I was assured that I would get used to the sensation.

I checked out the Trek Domane.  A week before one of the staff at Bike Culture offered his 62cm 6-series Domane as a test ride, even allowing me to ride the Federal Highway if I so chose. I rode a mere 7.5km (I’d already ridden the Fed a bit that morning) with a stupid smile on my face.  The ride was smooth and lovely despite skinny tyres pumped to the max and my riding over bumps.

While I was still making my mind up I stumbled upon the Cannondale Synapse.  Apparently half of the people who test the Synapse and the Roubaix chose the Synapse.  Having ridden it I think that I can understand why; the damping seems to be throughout the frame, not just rotation at the saddle.


These bikes are sold at full retail with no discounting, though you might get some extras thrown in.  Then along comes the Tour de France and suddenly the specials come out. Both Trek and Cannondale dropped their prices by 20%, but not Specialized.  My research (well, research conducted by Velonews) showed that the Roubaix was best at absorbing big bumps but the Domane and Synapse were equal or better at small bumps.  The Trek seemed to offer more for the money and had allowed for fitting mudguards.  I’m sure that a proper accounting would show any differences to be minor and/or justified by other factors, but take 20% off and it’s hard to stretch to the Specialized.  The Cannondale looks boss with its paint scheme and bold decals and 20% off put it under $3000 for Ultegra groupset with nice wheels or under $2200 for 105.

The decider

Three great bikes and two great bike shops; so how to decide.

It looked like I’d blown the Trek with the last three 62cm Domanes sold out in the previous week leaving only a 60cm 4.5 in the shop. But I had a quick test ride with the saddle at maximum height and it felt the right size.  Perhaps I was in-between sizes.  Brent at Bike Culture put my name on the bike to hold it, but insisted on a fitting before he would sell it to me.

Thursday’s fitting was an immediate success.  Brent had dropped the saddle 20mm from the maximum I’d ridden it at a few days before.  Now wearing my cycling shoes and pedals (as opposed to my mountain bike boots and plastic pedals) combined with the lower saddle the size seemed to be almost exactly right.  A second opinion from George and a wider saddle (with titanium rails, no less!) shifted slightly forward and the job’s a good’un.

After the fitting I kept my pedals on the bike… I guess I’d made up my mind.

Comments welcome

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.